Wx Feature · Weather & music

The song that taught us a ship's name.

If you know the name of exactly one Great Lakes freighter, chances are Gordon Lightfoot taught it to you.

November 10, 1975 · Lake Superior · 3 min read

Illustration of a Great Lakes freighter in a snowy November gale with huge waves breaking across the deck

The last voyage

  1. Nov 9, 1975

    Iron ore leaves Wisconsin for Detroit

  2. Nov 10, evening

    Snow, ~25 ft waves, water on deck

  3. Around 7 PM

    “We are holding our own.”

  4. Minutes later

    Lost 17 miles from Whitefish Bay

  5. August 1976

    Lightfoot's song reaches the world

A news report became a song

In 1975, the Canadian songwriter read an Associated Press report and then a Newsweek account of a ship lost on Lake Superior.

By the following August, people who had never seen the lake were listening to "The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald."

Fifty-one years ago this week

The Fitzgerald was carrying iron ore from Wisconsin to Detroit. On the evening of November 10, snow cut visibility, waves reached roughly 25 feet, and water swept across the deck.

The ship was leaning to one side. Both radars were out. When a nearby freighter checked in around seven, the answer came back:

"We are holding our own."

The Fitzgerald sank about 17 miles from the entrance to Whitefish Bay. All 29 men aboard died.

29

Men aboard. None survived.

~25 ft

Waves on Lake Superior that evening.

17 mi

From the shelter of Whitefish Bay.

A detail you can see on a map

Trace the ship's route southeast toward the bay. Now picture waves rolling across that line, striking the freighter nearly broadside.

Researchers who reconstructed the storm found that the ship reached that stretch of water just as conditions were at their worst.

Along the same route six hours earlier or later, the crew would have missed the peak.

Exactly what happened in the ship's final moments remains uncertain.

Mariners' Church, Detroit

Lightfoot gave listeners a way to remember the ship. At Mariners' Church in Detroit, the remembrance has a different sound.

Each November 10, the bell rings 29 times, once for each man.

Hear the song

The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald

Gordon Lightfoot's 1976 recording. Press play, then read the timeline again — every verse is in it.

A windy pond: glassy calm water along the near bank where the wind starts, choppy white-capped water toward the far bank
Same breeze, two shores: calm where the wind starts, choppy where it has crossed the water.

Something to notice

Watch the fetch

Next time you're beside a pond on a windy day, look at the water along the bank the wind is blowing from. Then look across at the bank it's blowing toward.

The breeze can be the same on your face while the two shores look quite different. The distance wind travels over open water is called fetch.

On a pond, you can often see its effect in a few hundred yards. On Lake Superior, that same detail belongs in the story of a ship.

This is how you weather

More than a forecast. All things Wx.

Your sky, local events, and the surprising ways weather shapes everyday life. One free email every Thursday.

Build my WxWeekly